A Musical Arxiv Experiment

20 Jun 2018 . category: DL . Comments

This post is inspired by researcher Janelle Shane and her blog aiweirdness.com, where she trains neural networks and lets them “be weird” :slightly_smiling_face:

Shane recently experimented with generating metal band ice cream flavors1, and my mentor Natasha and I (and a lot of Twitter) were highly entertained by them. We chatted about how I could generate some weird things during my OpenAI Scholar summer too. And since I’m working in deep learning with data about songs, we thought:

song titles + deep learning paper titles from arXiv2 = something hilarious???

Fickle Alchemy

Throughout my experimentation this week, these two sets of titles tried their darndest not to mix with each other - so sad! Many, many of the results were clearly either only influenced by deep learning:

Structural Model for Deep Learning for Parallel Problem Evolutional Recognition

Quee Reflet : Semi-Supervised A Learning-Model and Hierarchical Variational Architrate Networks for Invementation Selection

…or only influenced by songs:

Love Me Down (Manis Edit)

Boy (feat. Stron The Remix)

But right at the beginning, after just 2 training epochs and 9 samples, things we’re looking promising with these samples:

Flexing To The Study

Embedding feat. Cetya Readm

Amazing! Thanks to textgenrnn, this fun side experiment was all set to be a breeze, right?

Well, I got misleadingly lucky on those very first two epochs because my samples didn’t achieve hilarity like that again for a while. I probably generated well over 500 samples total. Things got a bit frustrating - I was mostly sampling boring-sounding deep learning paper titles.

But occasionally, the titles would play together as intended!

What seemed to help

Overall, my strategy was to encourage song/arXiv mixing by ensuring my network didn’t overfit to any particular training data.

  • A character-based network: my word-based experimentation seemed to result in even less arXiv/song mixing - plus textgenrnn is robust enough to still generate real words even while predicting a character at a time!
  • Higher temperatures: this let the network be ‘creative’ in its sampling by letting it predict lower probability characters to continue a sequence.
  • Dropout: this purposefully added some chaos to the network by randomly removing parts of the text while training.
  • Smaller max_length: this forced the network to work with a smaller memory by limiting the number of previous characters it could use to predict the next character.
  • Fewer epochs: this limited training time because textgenrnn is so robust that it quickly gets too good at telling the difference between songs and arXiv papers.
  • Mixing up the titles in a single text file: Shane mentioned that she (accidentally) pre-trained on only metal bands first and then used transfer learning to add in ice cream flavors. I tried this too, but the network seemed to immediately forget what the first thing it learned was and would just generate the second thing. This is known as catastrophic forgetting, which is the tendency for a neural network to completely erase what it learned about a first task when training on a second task in sequence. I got better results from just mixing the two sets of titles together and training in one go.
  • Balancing the number of titles from each set: this encouraged the network to learn from each set evenly.

I would definitely still get meh results, but adjusting these configurations seemed to improve chances of generating something fun.

Text generation is a messy affair

I think the textgenrnn project says this well in its disclaimer:

You will not get quality generated text 100% of the time, even with a heavily-trained neural network … NN text generation often generate lots of texts and [you’ll need to] curate/edit the best ones afterward.

And indeed, lots of curating and editing went into my ‘best of’ list!

Best of

After much tinkering and sampling, I did eventually achieve some fun mashup titles! Here are my favorites:

Flexing To The Study

Embedding feat. Ceyta Readm

Strong (feat. Salial Networks)

Moon (feat. Ligoning for Structured Remix)3

Completion and Continuous remix

State (Feat. Kanna Alignment Algorithms)

Like You Way To (Original Learning4 from a Hadcer convex framework)

Space Camera & Anomaly5

Correction in Remix

Automatic Samples for sea Remix

Silver (Sving Recognitive Network prooft Remix)

A Subspaces

Learning Theory (Live Self Model)6

A Problems of Gents

Task2Quous Dreams

Drop Loud

DeepSEGK: A Reconstruction7

DeepMe (feat. Remix)

Framework for Subspace (Dance of Resolutional Networks)

An Every of Localization Me Down (feat. A. Gradi)

Deep Sentiment of Character8

Semantic Segmentation in Semantic Segmentation

You can check out my work notebook for the messier results (and check out older commits too with more samples).

This was a lot of fun for me! People like Janelle Shane sharing experiments like these are what got me interested in text generation in the first place :slightly_smiling_face: I hope you enjoyed this as well!

Follow my progress this summer with this blog’s #openai tag, or on GitHub.


  1. And shout out to the Austin middle school coding class who provided Shane with the original dataset of 1,600 ice cream flavors - sweeet! 

  2. arXiv (pronounced like ‘archive’) has become the go-to open repository for the latest deep learning papers. The paper titles I used here were grabbed from the Brundage Bot collection of arXiv papers

  3. The most surefire way my network found to create a mashup title was to add “remix” to the end. 

  4. This reminded me of tracks that add “(original mix)” or “(original score)” to the end. 

  5. Could also be a hipster band name. 

  6. Live tracks too, huh? 

  7. Nice album title as well IMO. 

  8. The last two didn’t actually mix with song titles at all… but they still seemed musical to me. 


Nadja does not particularly enjoy writing about herself.